TThe Jasmine Star Show
← All episodes
Shelby Saap08 July 2025

From Objections to YES: The High-Ticket Sales Secrets You Need with Shelby Saap

5Frameworks
10Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster0:15:46

Great Salespeople Are Made Through Repetition

Shelby rejects the idea that confidence and communication ability must exist before someone enters sales. She says repeated conversations, close feedback between language and earnings, and deliberate refinement developed the conviction observers later assumed was natural.

  • Shelby says she did not initially know how to talk to people well.
  • Repeated exposure to different personalities improved her communication.
  • Immediate financial feedback encouraged deliberate refinement.
  • Practice created the confidence people later perceived as innate.

“But sales made me that.”

Shelby Saap · 0:16:20

“you do have to practice in order to be that way and make money.”

Shelby Saap · 0:16:20
#sales practice#confidence#communication#skill building

Explainer· 1

Explainer0:17:22

How Shelby Rebuilt an Aggressive Sales Script Around Her Own Authority

Male trainers taught Shelby an aggressive pest-control script built around being the technician or “bug boy.” Because that persona did not fit her, she retained the authority structure but presented herself as the route manager who supervised the service team, creating a credible role aligned with how customers perceived her.

  • Shelby preserved the underlying authority while changing the persona.
  • She positioned herself as responsible for schedules and service quality.
  • The adapted language avoided pretending she performed technical work.
  • A fitting script can retain the mechanism without copying another seller's style.

“I had to kind of take the bones of what they were training me and refine it into what would work for me.”

Shelby Saap · 0:17:22

“I'm the route manager in charge of the schedule”

Shelby Saap · 0:18:11
#sales scripts#women in sales#authority#adaptation

Story· 5

Story0:07:05

The LinkedIn Messages That Launched Shelby Saap's Sales Career

While juggling multiple college jobs, Shelby Saap realized hourly work capped her income. After repeatedly messaging a successful entrepreneur she admired, she met him at Carvana's headquarters, heard that sales was a foundational success skill, and enrolled herself in a door-to-door pest-control job in Minnesota.

  • Shelby stacked several jobs while attending college.
  • Hourly pay made her feel financially capped.
  • Persistent LinkedIn outreach secured a meeting with a mentor.
  • She chose door-to-door sales after being told to learn the art of selling.

“I was just looking for that one vehicle.”

Shelby Saap · 0:07:23

“he's like, you need to learn the art of sales.”

Shelby Saap · 0:09:10
#career origin#mentorship#linkedin#door-to-door sales
Story0:10:28

How an 18-Year-Old Made $70,000 in One Summer

Shelby describes working from early morning until late evening selling pest control door to door. Despite beginning with almost no product knowledge, she completed the demanding season and earned $70,000 in three months, while many peers spent their summer socializing.

  • Workdays ran roughly from 6:30 a.m. to 10:30 p.m.
  • Her first near-sale failed because she did not know customers could switch providers.
  • The first summer produced $70,000 in earnings.
  • She returned exhausted but convinced sales had changed her opportunities.

“The price sheet they call it on the way to my very first day on the doors.”

Shelby Saap · 0:11:09

“$70,000.”

Shelby Saap · 0:12:33
#door-to-door sales#earnings#resilience#early career
Story0:12:09

The Hidden Emotional Work of Leading a Sales Team

In her second summer, Shelby recruited a mixed team and earned $150,000 while continuing to sell personally. She discovered that sales management required supporting representatives through repeated rejection and hostility, not merely teaching scripts or tracking results.

  • Only four of roughly 10 to 12 recruits completed the season.
  • Shelby balanced personal selling with responsibility for team morale.
  • Representatives called after long runs of rejection and hostile encounters.
  • Helping another person develop an income-producing skill felt better than earning alone.

“selling with a team is completely different because you're responsible for other people's emotions.”

Shelby Saap · 0:14:29

“It feels better than myself making that money.”

Shelby Saap · 0:15:29
#sales leadership#team management#rejection#coaching
Story0:38:19

Why She Sells Started With Calls Before Becoming a Program

Shelby did not begin by packaging a large course. She shared sales content, trained women through individual and group Zoom calls, learned what participants needed, and then structured She Sells around training, confidence development, certification, and access to employment opportunities.

  • Audience demand emerged through social-media content.
  • Early delivery used one-to-one and group calls.
  • Direct teaching revealed the need for structured training.
  • Participants wanted both skill development and access to real offers.
  • The final program combined education with a placement platform.

“I was just I loved sales, I loved teaching other people, so that's what I was doing.”

Shelby Saap · 0:39:00

“These women wanted structured training, and then they also wanted an opportunity.”

Shelby Saap · 0:39:22
#offer creation#course design#she sells#entrepreneurship
Story0:42:34

Shelby's Tic-Tac-Toe Twist on “Sell Me This Pen”

Asked to sell a pen, Shelby avoids the familiar feature pitch and instead starts a tic-tac-toe game with a $100 prize, making the $10 pen the means of participating. The demonstration shows how creativity can capture attention before the standard exercise triggers resistance.

  • The pen becomes access to an attractive opportunity rather than the product itself.
  • The proposed prize changes the perceived economics of the purchase.
  • The game interrupts expectations surrounding the familiar sales exercise.
  • Creative presentation can earn attention before resistance forms.

“Would you like to play tic tac toe with me? The winner gets $100. You have nothing to lose.”

Shelby Saap · 0:42:52

“The pen cost $10 and I'll loan you the pen if you pay me in your profits.”

Shelby Saap · 0:42:52
#sell me this pen#creativity#demonstration#sales story

Tool· 2

Tool0:24:09

What to Do When a Partner Joins the Follow-Up Call

If an absent decision-maker joins a follow-up sales call, Shelby says the seller must rebuild the value rather than simply asking whether the couple discussed the offer. The process restarts in a conversational form: recap the earlier discussion, ask for the new participant's perspective, revisit pain points, and take them through the offer before price.

  • Do not resume the close where the previous call ended.
  • The new participant has not experienced the original value-building process.
  • Recap prior findings without repeating the script robotically.
  • Ask the new decision-maker to add or correct their perspective.
  • Revisit discovery, offer value, and benefits before discussing price.

“The biggest mistake you could possibly make is just picking up right where you left off and being like, so like, did you guys talk…”

Shelby Saap · 0:24:18

“You have to start the pitch all over because the decision maker needs the value built.”

Shelby Saap · 0:24:37
#follow-up calls#decision makers#sales process#couples
Tool0:41:08

The Fastest Way to Evaluate a High-Ticket Sales Closer

Shelby recommends reviewing a candidate's recorded or mock sales call rather than relying on written applications alone. After assessing the call, the offer owner can interview the candidate about experience and engagement, then provide complete program materials so the closer can learn the offer.

  • Ask candidates for a Loom or sales-call recording.
  • Evaluate real communication rather than text alone.
  • Use mock calls when candidates cannot share client recordings.
  • Interview for experience, training, and involvement.
  • Provide organized program materials during onboarding.

“You should be asking them to send over a loom.”

Shelby Saap · 0:41:18

“I don't like to look at text from a closer. I want to see their actual sales call.”

Shelby Saap · 0:41:18
#hiring#sales closers#loom#onboarding

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway0:21:37

Never Assume the Husband Is the Decision-Maker

Shelby explains that a salesperson can lose trust by directing attention toward the person stereotyped as the decision-maker. When approaching a couple, she recommends acknowledging the woman first, reducing competitive tension, and treating both partners as relevant participants rather than assuming who controls the purchase.

  • Attention patterns can trigger defensiveness before the pitch begins.
  • Acknowledging the overlooked partner helps lower their guard.
  • Gender is not a reliable proxy for purchasing authority.
  • Both participants should receive respect and an appropriate role in the conversation.

“the biggest mistake a lot of people make, too, is they think that the husband is the decision maker.”

Shelby Saap · 0:23:05

“That is a mistake you cannot make.”

Shelby Saap · 0:23:23
#couples#decision makers#rapport#gender assumptions